Results and Proposed Improvements Rubric

 

0 Points

1 Point

2 Points

3 Points

4 Points

Completion of Assessment Data Gathering

Failed to submit work

Failed to gather data for any outcome

Gathered data for some outcomes

Gathered data for most outcomes

Gathered data for all outcomes

Specificity of Assessment Data Documentation

Failed to submit work

Offered limited or vague data detail for all results (few sources; did not always include the number of participants, only the percent participating)

Offered comprehensive and specific data detail for some results (used various sources; included the number of participants, not just the percent participating)

Offered comprehensive and specific data detail for most results (used various sources; included the number of participants, not just the percent participating)

Offered comprehensive and specific data detail for all results (used various sources; included the number of participants, not just the percent participating)

Criteria for Success and Proposed Improvements

Failed to submit work

Offered no plans for improvement where success criteria were not met

Offered detailed plans for apt and appropriate improvements for some success criteria that were not met

Offered detailed plans for apt and appropriate improvements for most success criteria that were not met

Met criteria for success for all outcomes assessment measures OR offered detailed plans for apt and appropriate improvements for all success criteria that were not met

Assessment Leads to Program Improvements

Failed to submit work

No improvements have been made to the program or to the program’s assessment processes in the past 3 years

Assessment has led to improvements to the program's assessment processes in the past 3 years

Assessment has led to improvements to the program itself (curricular changes, etc.) in the past 3 years, BUT it is not clear if changes have been reassessed to determine impact

Assessment has led to improvements to the program itself (curricular changes, etc.) in the past 3 years AND have been reassessed to determine impact

Outcomes are Reassessed to Determine Student Learning Trends

Failed to submit work

No assessed program outcome results are compared to any prior results to identify trend data

Assessment result trends are discussed in vague terms BUT no data evidence is provided nor analyzed

Assessment result trends are clearly identified AND data evidence OR analysis is provided (but not both)

Assessment result trends are clearly identified AND data evidence AND analysis is provided